As I compared the candle data across 3 brokers and found out there is issue in the candle data across multiple instruments mostly in the future charts.
Check below JSW STEEL FUT MAY - 14:55 candle example. Compared the olhc with upstock and grow it is not matching but intresting upstock and grow are matching
Upstock:O:1293.70 H:1294.50 L:1291.40 C:1292.40
Grow: O:1293.70 H:1294.50 L:1291.40 C:1292.40
Dhan: O:1293.70 H:1294.50 L:1292.70 C:1292.70
Due to media limitation I can’t upload the screenshot of grow and upstock
Exchanges provides candles data separately from tick by tick data. Broker can directly display the historical data from the exchanges or can calculate from the tick by tick data at their end. You can match with TradingView data as well. In this case, TradingView data is matching with Dhan but not with Upstox and Groww.
yes this is happening with dhan. I use supertrend indicator in one strategy so sometimes in dhan i get opposite signal and in fyers, tradingview and upstox i don’t get that same signal. That time it confuses a lot. I feel like dhan is less accurate data among all because all shows same data and in high value there might be high chances of dhan showing low value than the other firms and in low value it show little higher value. Hope dhan will correct it soon.
This bug is there from the beginning on tv.dhan.co. When you change the number of charts in a layout then the indicator value changes. When you load the more historical data by scrolling left then also the chart value changes. This behavior is inconsistent, some time it works and most of the time it doesn’t.
Yes I have used multiple broker over past 6 years, every brokers can miss live ticks, this is a technological thing which can be fixed with tick by tick chart data.
@Goal_Archiver In that case whatever co-founder says in any post doesn’t matter. At the end of the day, the retail need charts with consistent technical indicators value. tv.dhan.co charts being the most inconsistent one.
One is from fyers and one is from dhan. check indicator value. those are different. Fyers is having same value as in tradingview.
Fyers showing supertrend 23690.48 and dhan is showing 23685.32
Seems like you are comparing Nifty 50 with Nifty May Fut on the two platforms, which might lead to different indicator values. Also, do ensure that the data frame is loaded in same dimension on both the charts before making the comparison.
This is a library behaviour - when values are computed on the library layer, the data is computed as it loads. This is something you will find across charting libraries except TradingView.com, where these values are calculated on the backend and then streamed over.
