Why Do Option Sellers Seem to Win More Often?

Many participants notice that option selling strategies appear to work more consistently over time. One concept often discussed behind this is the idea of a volatility premium.

In simple terms, options are priced based on expected movement in the market, which is reflected through implied volatility (IV). However, actual market movement over time, known as realised volatility (RV), is often lower than what was initially expected.

This difference between expected and actual movement is sometimes referred to as the volatility premium.

For example:

β€’ Implied Volatility (IV): 18%
β€’ Realized Volatility (RV): 12%
β€’ Difference: 6%

In such cases, option prices were based on higher expected movement, but the market moved less. This gap is where option sellers may benefit, as they collect premiums based on higher expectations.

This is why certain strategies are commonly observed:

β€’ Short straddles
β€’ Short strangles
β€’ Covered option approaches

However, this does not mean the outcome is always favourable.

During periods of sudden or high volatility:

β€’ Market movement can exceed expectations
β€’ Realised volatility can rise sharply
β€’ Risk can increase significantly for sellers

Because of this, many participants focus on:

β€’ Position sizing and exposure
β€’ Understanding changing volatility conditions
β€’ Avoiding participation during extreme phases
β€’ Managing overall risk rather than only returns

This creates an interesting perspective where outcomes depend not just on direction, but also on how expectations compare with actual movement.

Different experiences can offer useful insights into how traders understand and approach this concept.

What has been your observation? Do option sellers benefit from this difference over time?

4 Likes

This is a fundamental edge of volatility risk premiums. Option sellers demands extra margin for selling premiums.

coincidently we did a video on the same topic some time ago.

linking the same as video reference :

1 Like

I still believe that Option buying if done properly will definitely earn better result if the emotion part is avoided. Trade based on strategy, rules and SL….

3 Likes

It is not option sellers or option buyers. As SEBI report says few traders win, most other traders lose money :slightly_smiling_face:

if you set your entry & SL rules than you can trade anything…I just started using the Webhooks and directly placing orders without any emotional attachment. I just select the strike price and trade automatically. At the end of day I just analyze the trades. Lets see how far I can go…

1 Like

Agreed

  1. Option sellers win more often. Win%
  2. More Options sellers win more often - yoy
  3. Big outperformance is achieved more by the best OB