Hi Folks 
Welcome back to our weekly series where we explore the concepts, metrics, and nuances of algo trading to help you become a better-informed and a systematic trader.
This week’s topic is simple and slightly #controversial - Why an algo with a lower win rate might be better than an algo with a higher win rate.
Here we go, most traders obsess over one thing when it comes to strategies: “What’s the win rate?”
It sounds logical.
If you win more trades, you should make more money right….right?
Not quite.
In fact, some of the best traders in the world operate with win rates as low as 35–45%.
And they still outperform the majority of retail traders.
The reason is simple:
Trading is not about being right often.
It’s about making more when you’re right than you lose when you’re wrong.
That’s the game.
A high win rate feels good psychologically.
Winning 8 out of 10 trades gives confidence.
It creates the illusion of consistency.
But many traders chasing 80–90% accuracy are secretly doing this:
-
Taking tiny profits quickly
-
Holding losers too long
-
Refusing to accept small losses
-
Risking ₹5 to make ₹1
It works… until one bad trade wipes out weeks of gains.
This is why:
-
A trader with a 90% win rate can still lose money.
-
A trader with a 40% win rate can build serious wealth
The Only Formula That Matters
Your profitability depends on:
Expectancy
Expectancy = (Win Rate × Average Win) − (Loss Rate × Average Loss)
Let’s compare two traders to understand this.
Trader A and Trader B
This is the power of asymmetric risk-reward.
Most trend-following and momentum systems or strategies naturally have lower win rates.
Why?
Because they:
-
Cut losses quickly
-
Let winners run
-
Aim for large moves
-
Avoid revenge trading
You’ll take many small losses.
But one strong trend can pay for 5–10 failed trades.
The psychological advantage most traders ignore:
A low win rate strategy is emotionally uncomfortable.
You must accept:
-
Frequent small losses
-
Waiting for big moves
-
Long periods of frustration
-
Looking “wrong” often
Ironically, the obsession with “being right” is what keeps many traders unprofitable.
Focus on These Metrics Instead
Instead of just asking:
“What’s the win rate?”
Also ask:
-
What’s the average risk-reward ratio?
-
How much do winners outperform losers?
-
What’s the maximum drawdown?
-
Is the strategy scalable?
-
Can I execute it consistently?
Because in trading:
Accuracy is vanity.
Risk management is survival.
Expectancy is wealth creation.
And that’s why win rate alone is one of the most misunderstood metrics in trading.
Even some of the best-performing algos on Stratzy or Dhan Algos recently have win rates in the 40–50% range - yet they continue to outperform because their wins are significantly larger than their losses.
Happy Algo Trading 
- Team Stratzy