Arbitrage Trading between NSE & BSE - the opportunities rarely exists!

Saw social media post on this topic and thought to put down some notes.

No matter how exciting this sounds on the paper, that is arbitrage trading - find price differences between both exchanges and make a trade, say buy that on NSE and sell it on BSE (or vice versa) - these don’t come up that easily and are extremely rare. Some reasons for that..

  • There may be some real and meaningful differences between spot prices on the two exchange, at some time in the day - say it is ~1%, what isn’t factored is the transaction costs - which includes brokerage, exchange charges, etc, etc. Post these charges, the only one not making money is the trader!
  • Yes, now you get it. It is good for brokers, but not good for you!
  • Liquidity differences, the transaction volumes between BSE and NSE are way to disproportionate. On Dhan, we allow you see this exchange wise in the Markets section. So you may enter one side of the transaction, but may get stuck in execution on the exit leg.
  • To capture arbitrage, you have need entry and exit legs, well at least the exit leg on a limit prices. Low liquidity on exhchanges, either of it - will reduce the possibility of trade execution.
  • Price ticks between exchanges earlier were 0.05 paisa, so on small stocks the difference in spot prices would be considerable in % terms. However now the tick has been reduced to 1 paisa or 0.01. So the arbitrage opportunities have shrunk even further.

Trading opportunities don’t come that easy with exchange arbitrage :slight_smile:

5 Likes

Besides collocated algos at exchange ensure that any real opportunities quickly vaporize before the retail can manifest realised profits :laughing:

Yes that one too @t7support

1 Like

Not necessarily :grinning_face:

@PravinJ I would like Dhan to see it in a different way now that Dhan has already ventured into AI. Can AI help in highlighting a possible arbitrage or not is the main point and how is the platform built to show this to the customers? Instead of mentioning that its problematic, a right approach would be to brainstorm and see how AI can be leveraged to a give choice of Arbitrage to the customers using the platform.

Let us know if you find something useful :blush: