Hello @t7support
We have pushed some updates. Now, exit all closes sell leg before buy leg.
Will try to replicate freeze limit scenario here again.
1 Like
I tried this today. While sell leg did get closed the buy leg was kept open. Please look into this.
Freeze quantity issue still persist.
3 Likes
I tried to exit all positions , however it does not exit SELL legs first , creating multiple clicks to exit all positions. A basic functionality missing and long due.
3 Likes
Still exit all not closing sell leg first. So buy leg remain open and have to be closed again.
1 Like
RMS policy. You cannot exit all positions at once, (RMS POLICY)
While i tried to explain them (Dhan) all the time .
In simple credit or debit spread or inn Calendar spread or whatever you have to exit sell leg first then buy leg exit. (In between whatever slippage we face is thats depend on your luck ) ( i have face lot of negative slippage of that) but RMS POLICY is very important.
Only thing i don’t like about Dhan is there RMS POLICY about exit all (all other broker has facility to exit all positions at one click except Dhan) (Its personally my experience)
Just a simple question to @PravinJ and all …
If somebody has taken positions of 3 lots of credit or debit spread on 1 lakh of capital, can he or she exit positions at one click ?
Please explain 
Hello @t7support
Over here, you are selecting few positions and then exiting ‘selected positions’ only. In this case, the orders are sent directly, without slicing or Sell order before Buy order.
If you do ‘Exit All’, in that case both freeze quantity won’t exceed and sell will be exited before buy.
The exit button becomes active once I select one or more of the open positions. So I guess the intent is to select those and then exit those selected positions. The button is also marked like that “Exit Selected Positions”
1 Like
Hello @t7support
Yes, correct. As you highlighted, the purpose for exiting selected positions is to give user discretion on which positions to exit. But over here, the logic of exiting sell first and then buy is not implemented.
The reason for having a single click “Exit all” with these features was to provide quick exit. However, in scenario where user is actually selecting specific position and then exiting, it becomes difficult to implement these logics.
@Hardik in the video above the order was rejected due to a freeze quantity issue. To split these like an iceberg order wouldn’t be a problem I guess.
I understand the difficulty in implementing the logic to select the hedge leg first during partial execution.
1 Like
Hello @t7support
Yes, noted. Will look into implementation of freeze quantity based slicing when using ‘Exit selected positions’.
1 Like
@Hardik today something weird happened. I selected 3 open positions on sensex (one short leg and two buy legs). Clicked on exit selected positions. Short leg was closed. Two buy legs remained. Then I manually closed both buy legs. Soon after I saw a sell leg and buy leg appear under open positions. Closed them again. Again one closed sell leg reappeared. All this on the latest mobile app.
Am not sure whether the problem is with the frontend ui or the exit all feature itself.
1 Like
i have mentioned this issue lot of time, just because of RMS policy we cannot exit all positions at a single click. We have to exit sell leg first then buy leg .
I have requested many time …
Hope for the best
(Weather is it possible ?)
Hello @t7support
This is highly unlikely. I will check if we noticed something similar on the backend.
Can you confirm around what time did you notice this irregularity?
@Amitagsk The criteria of exit sell leg first and then buy is simply because of how margins work and hedge benefit is provided. This is how we ensure real-time margin calculations are always correct and as per the guidelines.
This was after 3:15 PM on 21 Jun. Unlikely issue happened 
1 Like
Exit All in its current form is useless for active traders having a position size above the freeze limit. Add to this the hedge leg issue, this is a feature that will just cause confusion while trading due to failed orders…
Hello @t7support
Freeze limit issue has been handled in both Exit All and Exit Selected Positions. Are you still facing this issue?
On the hedged leg issue, it cannot be handled if the hedged leg is sent for execution before the main leg. Although this has been handled where we send the orders sequentially, situations still might arise where the order is rejected.
Yes. sometimes it goes through. Sometimes it doesn’t and order fails with freeze quantity exceeded error.
In grouped positions arrange the short positions at top and long positions below. Then hedge leg will exit only later when orders are sent sequentially.
Can you share any Order ID for this, if faced next time. We will get this checked.
For exit all and exit selected, we already do this. The reason for orders still failing is the sequence at which it gets executed on the exchange which can differ.
