@PravinJ @Hardik @Dhan …
Requested to implement LTP% close .option along with ATR, Traditional method for the renko and point and figure charting method … the request asked is of not such a hard to work and deploy in your system …
I really don’t understand why such a tiny thing is taking months of time. As a trader, and a investor in your brokerage firm, has asked for a very tiny request which can help him to take a firm decision is not been taken care by your brokerage house… it makes me feel low for selecting your house for my investment needs …
Thank you guys for keep me Wait for years …
And I have seen things which are no use in trading are given more of important…
I have seen in this industry there is more noise… and most of the people fall prey to such things …
Thank you
As I was updated by your team, that trading view library once give you access for that,we will update it.
Trading view does not have candlestick identification ?. It has ,then also you dhan development dhan candle identification,right . Why can’t my request be taken by your development team. It’s not a rocket science, need last close price on % basis for using for point and figure, renko, line break . Option for box size assignment method ,along with ATR, Traditional.
I hope this will be updated in coming days …
Thank you
Regards
Sunny behl
Such type of request is never heard,seen,replied.
It’s really bad to see such response.
Hello @sunny123
Looks like this thread got missed earlier, apologies for the same.
I completely understand your perspective and the frustration you might feel seeing features being developed on top of charts while your request remains pending. Please know that we value every community post equally and strive to prioritize them based on feasibility and the overall value they add to the product.
Regarding functionality such as the type of candles and their construction, this remains within the scope of the TradingView library, which unfortunately we cannot directly modify. This is why we haven’t been able to implement LTP % Close as an input for the charts, though you can still configure ATR and the Traditional method.
We’re actively in touch with the TradingView team to explore possibilities for this functionality. However, such enhancements require development from their side, which can take time.
Hardik I am able to do it manually, by just taking the percentage ltp and plot …on traditional method .
If I can do that and plot noiseless chart on manual efforts, why can’t it be done by just integrated it at back end …
Sharing you screenshot, by using 1 min timeframe,as this charts need data,not time …
@Hardik @PravinJ .here with sharing the renko chart doing it manually,were I am trading at 1min time frame, here renko has nothing to do with timeframe, it needs only tickdata. When the plotiing can be done on manual why can’t we have some requirement to just assign the method …
Here doing it manually takes a lot of time to check pday last traded price and calculate your investment or trading change in % …
I am requesting you to pls pls get this function…in your platform
Thank you
@Hardik If Define Edge team can do LTP% based PnF chart then why not Dhan. Point raised by @sunny123 is absolutely correct. It is not a rocket science.
@Nawaz_Ansari you are right …
I have noticed that @Dhan is looking to attract more customer by Highlighting TV on charts etc .
I have asked for many small things which are really useful for trading, I have even asked for scanx there so called scanner, which is used for intraday scanning on OHLC methods, that is only for day traders, were most of the people lose, there scanner have been designed as per there parameters were the TF is of 5min and 15 min …
Make a system were you can attract investors also .
Have asked for a headmap in scanx for the sectorwise,but they have something other story to tell, there UI is shit,with so confused layout,
Trending stocks should have what’s moving and dragging any index, here they have what is more bought at dhan,and sold at dhan 
…
Here investor are been attracted by showing what most of the people are doing,do the same and genarate revenue for them …
Lots of more stuff …
I am just pointing some …
Give the people what they need,not to accept what you give …
Thank you
Can anyone trust this logic ?
Library updation from trading view does not allow…
@Dhan when you are building your own indicators like open interest,OI profile, and many more …you can only find them,in your indicator list which are made by dhan …
Why can’t % based close price be done …
The excuses cannot be digest
Have made my friends also to open an account in dhan,in a hope that they listen to clients ,but seeing such lame excuses from them,I have shifted to definedge