Quicko fno pnl data mismatch

Hi team,

I am facing issues while filing income tax on Quicko. When I import Dhan FNO data on quick it is wrong, everything starting from PNL to turnover are wrong numbers. Also, it is not just on Quicko, the same thing is happening on the CLEAR TAX platform. Quicko and Clear tax both show correct data from my Zerodha account. I don’t know what is happening with Dhan data. Please help.

Thanks,
Ashish

1 Like

Problem is with the Dhan reports. Now I don’t see Dhan icon on the quicko site. They have removed it. @quicko

Yes, I contacted Quicko support. They said they have removed Dhan import option for now. They are working on enabling their own excel template. We can add trades their and import all data.

Also, the data in Dhan reports is not wrong, it is just misplaced between the two sheets(PNL and Tax pnl(AGTS)). So, Quicko and Clear tax are unable to understand it correctly.

It won’t help because you need the buy and sell date as per the transactions. There is a template for Cleartax, try filling that and you will go mad. with 1500+ transaction. You need to manually match the buy and sell transaction adjust the charges. Split the rows if you have sold in multiple tranches.

1 Like

If you weren’t aware, we have all been royally done this year by Team Dhan. :blush: Thanks to their state of the reports, which I have even reported 6 months back (if you check my profile posts), only to find irrelevant arguments such as we build based on usage and data.

They have also once told that backoffice is obsolete and integrated platform is the future. Welcome to the future, I guess.

2 Likes

So how to proceed? Just file using scrip-wise turnover data or wait for DHAN to provide correct trade wise report.

Dhan ne tho “guup ki goli lele hai”, they are not responding on any of these issues because I think they are busy inventing some “Z”,“T”,“R”…

1 Like

Hi @Ashish_Patel @PankajJ @thisisbanerjee @HIR

The issue is being fixed by Quicko team, this was disabled at their end without intimation to us.

1 Like

Problem is that even cleartax not able to process the Dhan FNO data. There is issue with the reports. Even manually we will not be able to process without the summary transactions giving the buy and sell date together.
Quicko - Loaded the data but calculations were all wrong
ClearTax - Clearly gave the message that failed to load data.

For these two - i could successfully upload the kotak, reliance and alice blue data

1 Like

@PravinJ
I cant see dhan login yet

2 Likes

@PravinJ Please integrate with Cleartax also in a proper manner. This year I had to take up a subscription of MProfit to sort out the taxes of all my family members because DHAN IS NOT WORKING.

Quicko wouldn’t dare disabling a broker like Zerodha without intimation. Please exercise greater and better control.

2 Likes

@PravinJ
STILL I DON’T SEE DHAN, “tax baru ke chod du ye saal”

1 Like

@PravinJ @quicko
lets move to clear tax now

Team at Quicko is working on this @HIR

@PravinJ @quicko
But will this be solved by 30th July?

@PravinJ Your team says DAHN stopped the integration with Quicko. Shouldn’t it be they stopped it?

Rather than providing me the report, they are saying we have noted the suggestion and no action on providing the Capital Gains Report.
What is this going on ?
@iamshrimohan

Dear Pankaj,

Greetings from the team at Dhan.

We’ve stopped the integration with quicko for now and LTGS & STGS doesn’t have dates mentioned on the same, we’ve made a note of your suggestions.

Hope this helps.

Best Regards,
Samuel
Dhan Customer Care

It is still not fixed, will it be fixed before 31st July?
@PravinJ

Hi @P3.arl

Welcome to MadeForTrade Community

Apologies for inconvenience

We suggest you refer to ClearTax for now. Our team is working on it with them.

Hi Divyesh,

Not sure if you went through the discussion on top. The interface with cleartax and Quicko is broken. Both are not able to process the Dhan reports

1 Like